2 min read

Gloria Carter, the mother of American rapper Jay-Z, spoke in September 2017 about coming out to her son as a lesbian, and how that conversation became the song “Smile”. The track appears on his album 4:44, released at the end of June 2017.

On the song, Jay-Z raps about his mother, a mother of four, having to hide her sexuality for years. Carter closes the track herself by reading a poem she wrote, titled “Living in the Shadows”.

How the song began

In an interview reported that week, Gloria Carter said she had started telling her son who she really was. She said that beyond being his mother, she wanted him to know the person she is and the life she lives.

She said Jay-Z became emotional, thinking she must have had a hard life. She told him her life had never been unhappy, only different. That conversation, she said, made him want to write a song about it.

Gloria Carter’s doubts

Carter admitted she was unsure when she first heard an early version of “Smile”. She said she had opened up to her son, not to the world, and his audience is huge.

The song came together after she read her poem to him. She said she had grown tired of the secrecy and of people wondering about her private life.

The reaction

When the song came out, Carter said she was overwhelmed by the response. Many people called to thank her, telling her that her story was their story too. She said she had not realised the effect it would have.

Listeners and critics singled out the song as one of the album’s most personal moments. The track was widely praised as one of the most personal moments on the album. Jay-Z, who is married to Beyonce, had made openness about family a theme across “Smile” and the rest of 4:44.

Get new stories by email

Practical guides on money, work, tech and culture. No spam, and you can leave at any time.